Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Pumpkin

The prettiest pumpkin in the patch is hiding a peanut butter secret. Our Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Pumpkin is a plump, rounded little gourd of smooth milk chocolate, finished with a tiny orange pumpkin and curling green vines right on top.

Inside is our own homemade peanut butter creme, whipped until it’s silky, creamy, and just sweet enough. We pipe it by hand into a pumpkin, then cover it in a thick coat of milk chocolate that gives way with a gentle snap. Cut one open and you’ll see the swirls of filling, which is usually when people stop admiring and start eating.

The decorating is a quiet kind of fancy. A swirl of bright orange, a dot of green for the stem, and a few piped vines make each one look like it was picked straight from a harvest table. It sits happily beside real pumpkins and pinecones, and it tastes a whole lot better.

These are made for a fall full of gatherings. Set a few on the Thanksgiving dessert board, tuck one into each place setting as a little surprise or add a handful to a fall gift box for a host, a teacher, or the peanut butter lover in your life.

Every pumpkin is shaped and decorated by hand in our kitchen, so each set of vines curls a little differently. That’s the charm of handmade.

Part of our fall and Thanksgiving collection, made fresh in small batches. Pop by and pick out a few for the season.